Are we the smartest?




 “Mum, what is intelligence?”

“Why, it is the quality that makes us humans the smartest beings on the planet!”

“Are all humans smart?”

“You definitely are! And I sure hope I am. For the others, well, it varies…”

“But how do you define it?”

“Let’s see… an accepted definition states that intelligence is our ability to understand complex ideas, adapt effectively to the environment, learn from experience, engage in various forms of reasoning, and, overcome obstacles by careful thought.[1] Does this answer your question?”

“…It sounds complicated!”

“Let me break it down for you. For one, it is your ability to understand complex ideas.”

“I don’t understand complex ideas! Does that mean I am not intelligent? ”

“Of course not! It just means that what’s complex for you might be easy for someone else, and what’s easy for you might be complex for others. It’s all subjective.”

“So we judge intelligence according to what is complex for us?”

“Yes, who else should it be for?”

“I just think that calling ourselves most intelligent based on our own standards is unfair!”

“But we cannot really ask animals to establish those standards!”

“No. We can, however, see if they can understand ideas that are complex for them. Subjective, like you said.”

“I agree. Many animals are considered intelligent. But understanding ideas is not the only measure of intelligence. There are others, such as learning from experience, on which our entire civilization is based. Without this ability, we’ll be just like animals.”

“Po learns from experience. And he is just a dog! He still remembers being punished for tearing my clothes. He won’t even go near a cupboard!”

“Yes, dear. Po is intelligent too. He is living with us, after all! You are forgetting the other attributes of intelligence.”

\“I remember something about overcoming obstacles.”

“Very good! Overcoming obstacles by careful thought. French philosopher Descartes said ‘Cogito ergo sum’. I think, therefore I am.”

“O c’mon mom! Don’t tell me that humans are the only creatures who think!”

“Of course not! Animals have shown remarkable problem solving and thinking abilities. But they do not have our range or depth.”

“Hmmmmm….”

“What are you thinking?”

“Don’t you know?”

“Haha! I'm no mind reader dear.”

“Then how do you know what animals think about?”

“I don’t. I wish I could!”

“But you just said that their thoughts lack depth!”

“Okay. Smart one! Tell me that animals engage in reasoning too. Can a mother-daughter ape have this discussion?”

“So how do animals sort their differences?”

“They fight, what else! Give into their primal instincts. Humans are evolved. We reason.”

“Uh… riots, massacres, bombings, blockades, conflicts, crusades, world wars……we reason?”

“Yes, we regress too. However, mostly we sit and discuss. It’s the smarter thing to do”

“It is. But compromise is not a human invention. The world thrives on it. Animals may not sit and talk, but they don’t 
always fight too. I’ve seen videos of animals sharing resources, understanding one another and reaching conclusions without raising fists. In fact, I haven’t seen much of it in our ‘evolved’ world.”

“Now dear, you have raised some very imperative points. There is one more though. No other being has so effectively learnt to adapt to the environment. Hot, cold, barren, overflowing – human ingenious makes survival possible. You get a polar bear to the Sahara desert, it’ll die. Get an Inuit, and you’ll have an igloo of sand.”

“I guess we do adapt very well.”

“See, there you go. Finally succumbing to human intellect!”

“But what about all that we leave behind? Toxic waste, burnt forests, animal extinction, global warming, to name a few! A polar bear might not survive in the Sahara, mother, but the Arctic is so much a better place with it.”

“Hmmm. I have to agree with you on that… It seems you have bested me after all. Not just me, the entire human race. Our intelligence isn’t the greatest. In fact, we are quite the fools for being so presumptuous…….”

“Oh, I wouldn't be so harsh mum. I guess to really understand intelligence is to underestimate the quality and overestimate ourselves. And that would truly be presumptuous.”

                                                                                                                                          

[1] Definition by Neissar et al., 1996

© 2012 www.iconoclastmemoirs.blogspot.com. All rights reserved.